HomeFinanceThe 2024 Election’s Other...

The 2024 Election’s Other Big Loser: Prediction Markets

Betting markets like Kalshi allow people to buy stakes in future outcomes, including election … [+]The Washington Post via Getty Images

In the aftermath of the 2024 presidential election, much attention has focused on the implications of President Trump’s historic return to the White House. Yet another significant story has emerged: the failure of prediction markets to provide reliable forecasting during the pivotal contest between Trump and his opponent, Kamala Harris.

Prediction markets are exchange-traded markets where participants can bet on the outcomes of future events. The theory behind them is actually compelling: by aggregating the views of numerous participants willing to put real money behind their beliefs, these markets may produce more accurate forecasts than polls or expert opinions. When functioning efficiently, the market price in a prediction market can represent the probability of an event occurring.

The landscape for prediction markets in the United States changed significantly this year when the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) was forced to allow Kalshi’s political betting markets. As a result of a court ruling, Americans could legally bet on election outcomes through this regulated U.S.-based platform. Along with offshore competitors like Polymarket and PredictIt, these venues promised to bring new clarity to electoral forecasting.

Instead, they delivered significant confusion and contradiction. Throughout the campaign, Kalshi and Polymarket sometimes showed different probabilities for the same outcome. One market would Trump as the likely winner while the other favored Harris or showed them evenly matched–a situation that should be impossible in efficient markets. In theory, such discrepancies create risk-free arbitrage opportunities: traders could bet on the lower-priced candidate in each market, guaranteeing a profit regardless of the outcome.

While transaction costs might explain small differences, the persistent large gaps across markets suggests other factors were at play. One is the apparent ability of individual traders to significantly move these markets. The most notable example was a French investor known as “Freddi9999,” whose large pro-Trump bets on Polymarket appeared to single-handedly shift that platform’s odds. There is speculation that Harris supporters may have responded by pushing up her price on Kalshi, effectively turning these prediction markets into another form of campaign advertising.

This phenomenon illustrates what economist Robert Lucas identified in his famous critique of economic policy evaluation: once a measure becomes a policy target, it loses its reliability as an indicator because people adjust their behavior in response. While Lucas was primarily concerned with monetary policy metrics, his insight applies equally to prediction markets. When these markets are viewed as influential indicators, they become vulnerable to manipulation by those seeking to shape public perception.

Investing Digest: Know what’s moving the financial markets and what smart money is buying with Forbes Investing Digest.

Get the latest news on special offers, product updates and content suggestions from Forbes and its affiliates.

Sign Up

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Service, and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. Forbes is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Some prediction markets remained inconsistent right up until election day, with PredictIt and Polymarket still showing conflicting probabilities just days before voters went to the polls. Some defenders point to how quickly these markets identified Trump as the winner on election night, before major networks made their official calls. However, this is hardly impressive. The New York Times election needle and other related indicators were similarly quick to suggest Trump’s advantage as results came in. In fact, betting markets were likely reacting to the same publicly available vote counts and analysis that informed the media forecasting tools, as opposed to providing unique insights.

This is not to say prediction markets are not useful. They can provide valuable information when properly structured and when participants are trading based on genuine information. However, the 2024 election demonstrated their limitations, particularly in high-stakes political contests where the incentive to manipulate outcomes is strong.

The lesson is clear: while prediction markets can be useful tools in our forecasting arsenal, their imperfect accuracy as well as vulnerability to manipulation, means they must be viewed as just one of many inputs in understanding likely outcomes. The 2024 election proved that these markets work best when they complement rather than replace traditional forecasting methods–and when we maintain healthy skepticism about their predictive power.

As we look ahead to future elections, we would do well to remember that no single forecasting tool is infallible. Betting markets offer useful insights at times, but the case for them having any more important role in society beyond as a source of entertainment, such as in a policy making context, is narrow. Sometimes, as in 2024, their greatest contribution might be showing us the limitations of our forecasting capabilities.

Follow me on Twitter or LinkedIn

Cre: James Broughel

- A word from our sponsors -

spot_img

Most Popular

More from Author

นักวิจัยด้านความปลอดภัยพบช่องโหว่ในฐานข้อมูลของ DeepSeek

DeepSeek บริษัทสตาร์ทอัพด้านปัญญาประดิษฐ์ของจีน ถูกนักวิจัยด้านความปลอดภัยค้นพบช่องโหว่ ซึ่งเป็นข้อมูลการสนทนาและคีย์ลับ หรือ Secret Keys กว่า 1 ล้านรายการ สร้างความกังวลเกี่ยวกับความเป็นส่วนตัวและความปลอดภัยของข้อมูลผู้ใช้ นักวิจัยด้านความปลอดภัยจาก...

Painting found at garage sale is a Van Gogh, experts say

A painting bought at a garage sale in Minnesota is a...

- A word from our sponsors -

spot_img

Read Now

Mr Nguyen Thang Long – The dream of elevating young designers at Global Student Fashion Week

In the Vietnamese fashion industry, Mr. Nguyen Thang Long is not only known as a passionate founder but also as a strong source of inspiration for the younger generation of designers. With firm belief in the talent and creative potential of young people, he has tirelessly worked...

Miss &Mister Celebrity Vietnam 2024 – Truong Thuy Trang & Doan Bao An – Image Representatives of GSFW

Truong Thuy Trang and Doan Bao An, winners of Miss & Mister Celebrity Vietnam 2024, have been appointed as Image Representatives for Global Student Fashion Week (GSFW) 2025. This marks a significant step in their careers while promoting Vietnamese fashion on the international stage. Truong Thuy Trang -...

นักวิจัยด้านความปลอดภัยพบช่องโหว่ในฐานข้อมูลของ DeepSeek

DeepSeek บริษัทสตาร์ทอัพด้านปัญญาประดิษฐ์ของจีน ถูกนักวิจัยด้านความปลอดภัยค้นพบช่องโหว่ ซึ่งเป็นข้อมูลการสนทนาและคีย์ลับ หรือ Secret Keys กว่า 1 ล้านรายการ สร้างความกังวลเกี่ยวกับความเป็นส่วนตัวและความปลอดภัยของข้อมูลผู้ใช้ นักวิจัยด้านความปลอดภัยจาก Wiz เปิดเผยว่าพวกเขาได้ค้นพบฐานข้อมูลสำคัญของ DeepSeek ที่เปิดเผยสู่สาธารณะโดยไม่มีการป้องกัน โดยข้อมูลที่พบประกอบไปด้วยประวัติการสนทนาของผู้ใช้งาน คีย์สำหรับยืนยันตัวตน API บันทึกระบบ และข้อมูลสำคัญอื่นๆ ซึ่งสามารถเข้าถึงได้โดยไม่มีข้อจำกัดใดๆ ทีมวิจัยของ Wiz ระบุว่าพวกเขาสามารถค้นพบฐานข้อมูลนี้ได้ภายในไม่กี่นาที โดยไม่ต้องผ่านกระบวนการยืนยันตัวตน ข้อมูลดังกล่าวถูกเก็บอยู่ในระบบจัดการข้อมูลโอเพ่นซอร์สที่เรียกว่า ClickHouse และมีบันทึกมากกว่า 1 ล้านรายการ Wiz ระบุว่าช่องโหว่นี้อาจทำให้แฮกเกอร์สามารถควบคุมฐานข้อมูลได้ทั้งหมด รวมถึงอาจเพิ่มสิทธิ์การเข้าถึงในระบบของ DeepSeek ได้ ซึ่งอาจนำไปสู่การโจมตีระบบภายในของบริษัท หลังจาก Wiz แจ้งเตือนเรื่องช่องโหว่ DeepSeek ได้ดำเนินการปิดฐานข้อมูลทันที อย่างไรก็ตาม ยังไม่มีข้อมูลแน่ชัดว่ามีใครเข้าถึงข้อมูลนี้ไปก่อนหน้าหรือไม่ นักวิจัยของ Wiz ให้สัมภาษณ์กับ Wired ว่าไม่แปลกใจเลยหากมีคนอื่นพบฐานข้อมูลนี้ก่อนพวกเขา เพราะมันถูกเปิดกว้างและค้นพบได้ง่ายมาก นอกจากนี้ พวกเขายังตั้งข้อสังเกตว่าระบบของ...

Painting found at garage sale is a Van Gogh, experts say

A painting bought at a garage sale in Minnesota is a previously unknown portrait by Dutch artist Vincent Van Gogh, according to a newly published expert analysis. It was made by Van Gogh during his stay at a psychiatric hospital in the south of France in 1889, experts commissioned...

Best red carpet looks at the 2025 Grammy Awards

The Grammy Awards are renowned for outlandish fashion. But on a night of tributes to first responders and victims of LA’s recent wildfires, many guests struck a comparatively restrained note at the Crypto.com arena on Sunday. The all-black trend seen at recent award ceremonies was embraced by everyone from Miley...

Meet the designer redefining lace for the 21st century

When British comedian and presenter Amelia Dimoldenberg stepped onto the red carpet to interview Sydney Sweeney in 2022, it only took a second for Dimoldenberg’s dress to reverse their roles. “This is amazing,” Sweeney said, reaching out to touch the presenters’ sleeveless black floor-length gown. The fabric —...

Anna Wintour takes off her iconic sunglasses for meeting with King Charles

Anna Wintour is rarely seen without her shades. But for a special occasion, she was prepared to break with tradition. The legendary Vogue editor-in-chief was presented with the Order of the Companions of Honour by King Charles III at Buckingham Palace on Tuesday. She was appointed to the order in...

Grammys and FireAid concerts expected to raise over $120 million for LA fire relief

The music industry came together for an ambitious Los Angeles fire relief effort the week of the Grammy Awards that is estimated to have raised more than $120 million. Of that, $9 million raised during the Grammys telecast on Sunday night, a representative for the Recording Academy told...

Miles Teller saved his recently deceased grandfather’s watch from Palisades Fire… and not much else

Miles Teller’s home was destroyed when the Palisades Fire ripped through his Los Angeles neighborhood last month, but he grabbed one very important item just in the nick of time. Teller recounted his harrowing experience evacuating his home in the Pacific Palisades – an affluent neighborhood in LA’s Westside that...

Kim Kardashian’s ‘Nobody Wants This’ mixup caused Adrien Brody’s Instagram to go ‘crazy’

Adrien Brody’s Instagram recently got a major surge in activity, all thanks to Kim Kardashian. “The Brutalist” actor recounted to late night host Jimmy Fallon on Monday’s episode of “The Tonight Show” how Kardashian mixed him up with Adam Brody in a message on her Instagram story last month raving...

Harrison Ford is ‘still happy’ he made ‘Indiana Jones 5’ despite underwhelming box office

It takes a lot to make Harrison Ford regret doing a project. This is especially true when it comes to the classic “Indiana Jones” franchise, in which Ford starred as the titular character, including the franchise’s fifth installment, 2023’s “Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny.” The movie grossed $60...

Ozzy Osbourne to reunite with Black Sabbath for farewell concert

Ozzy Osbourne has announced that the original members of Black Sabbath will play a concert together for the first time in 20 years. In a post on X, Osbourne revealed that he would reunite with Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler and Bill Ward to play one final show at Villa Park in...